Login
Register
Questions
Unanswered
Tags
Users
Ask a Question
About Us
Welcome to Anarchy101 Q&A, where you can ask questions and receive answers about
anarchism
from other members of the community.
¿Why don´t platfomists just join bigger marxist-leninist organizations available everywhere?
0
votes
I say this because one of their main theorists George Fontenis had his organization called Federation Anarcho Communiste run for parliamentary elections. Also they emphasize "theorectical unity, tactical unity". And also because they are against individualism which anarcho-communists like Malatesta and Kropotkin say are a part of anarchism. And also because as their Dielo Truda Platform says "In the social domain all human history represents an uninterrupted chain of struggles waged by the working masses for their rights, liberty, and a better life — In the history of human society this class struggle has always been the primary factor which determined the form and structure of these societies" and so they have a marxist view of history.
asked
8 months
ago
by
iconoclast
(
2,150
points)
platformism
platform
marxism
leninism
"because one of their main theorists George Fontenis had his organization called Federation Anarcho Communiste run for parliamentary elections." - that's how you know theyre not anarchists. do they want anarchy, or unity? unity as in? everybody "vote" for "anarchists" ?
—
8 months
ago
by
Redblood Blackflag
(
260
points)
2 Answers
0
votes
because we are anarchists.
answered
8 months
ago
by
sabotage
(
520
points)
Communism is not anarchy.
Anarchy is the lack of all government.
If I refuse to let other people say what to do with things I made with my own two hands, food I grew, a house I made..
it is taken from me by force.
Against my will.
My actions are governed by others.
No form of communism is anarchy.
—
8 months
ago
by
JaysThoughts
(
5,130
points)
–
edited
8 months
ago
by
dot
If you're going to mark my answer down, please at least be educational for me by saying why or how it was in error. Thank you.
—
8 months
ago
by
JaysThoughts
(
5,130
points)
–
edited
8 months
ago
by
anonymous
I love how your page says answers will never be deleted, yet you turn answers into comments and then "edit" them as you see fit, to basically have the same effect.
—
8 months
ago
by
JaysThoughts
(
5,130
points)
+1
vote
There's no such thing as "theoretical and tactical unity" between Anarchists and Marxists. Why should I become their ally, when we have a great example of failure of dictatorship of the proletariat, which is advocated by Marxism? Why should I help those Marxists, when I know what happened to Kronstadt rebels?
answered
6 months
ago
by
SydViking
(
360
points)
Related questions
0
votes
2
answers
Why do some anarchists hate on the Zapatistas?
asked
1 year
ago
by
peau_de_chat
(
340
points)
zapatista
autonomous
marxism
–3
votes
1
answer
What does "collectivism" have to do with anarchy?
asked
8 months
ago
by
Redblood Blackflag
(
260
points)
marxism
anarchy
contradiction
+1
vote
1
answer
What relevance does critical theory hold for anarchism?
asked
1 year
ago
by
vaguelyhumanoid
(
440
points)
analysis
critical-theory
marxism
anarchism
+4
votes
1
answer
Are there any good, distinctively anarchist, accounts of race?
asked
1 year
ago
by
asker
(
2,400
points)
race
marxism
0
votes
1
answer
What do Bookchin & co. mean by "anti-humanism"?
asked
1 year
ago
by
enkidu
(
5,680
points)
bookchin
terminology
marxism