Note that the site is in archived, read-only mode. You can browse and read, but posting is disabled.
Welcome to Anarchy101 Q&A, where you can ask questions and receive answers about anarchism, from anarchists.

Note that the site is in archived, read-only mode. You can browse and read, but posting is disabled.


+4 votes
I make good money where I work and live very comfortably because of it. Why should I care about some (more) exploited workers not making enough or having to work in shitty conditions? Their suffering doesn't affect me negatively in the least bit; in fact I'm aware that my comfort is derived from exploited laborers. So what's my incentive to have solidarity with these people that I've never met?

3 Answers

+3 votes
There is no inherent reason you should care. I just do. It comes naturally. Maybe it’s a result of my moralist socialization, maybe you could chalk it up to some kind of empathy instilled in me as a child by my parents, I don’t know.

But I also care for my own reasons. I am bored, stressed, lonely, and spiritually dead due to a world which assigns me a function for the sake of capital (or order, or civilization, etc). In this way I am alienated from my own life, which means the life I live doesn’t feel like something I can grasp or get a hold of in any way. Meaningful relationships, an interesting life, the ability to control my own fate; all these things have been robbed from me due to the material conditions of the world. It doesn’t provide any adventure; it’s been shaped for the sake of those previously stated things (capital, etc). At best I can continue to experience such despair, at worst I can starve to death. So I identify the woes I experience as being symptomatic of a larger system (civilization, capitalism, whatever you call it). For these reasons I want to destroy the system. If other people also want to destroy the system, then I tend to feel solidarity or affinity towards them.

I care about these people and their struggles because I understand that capitalism only works if everyone plays along. If these extra exploited people revolt in some way, the conflict that such a revolt brings has potential to generalize and possibly destroy the system. There used to be a dominating narrative that these ‘more exploited’ people are inherently more likely to be the agents of bringing about this destruction of alienation and exploitation. I’m not so sure if that’s true. But for me it isn’t their position of extra exploitation that leads me to feel solidarity with them, but rather if they are hating/attacking the system.

edited for grammar corrections/clarification.
by (4.0k points)
edited by
+3 votes
if you're not unhappy about the way the world works right now, then you shouldn't.
a. the fact that you make good money right now doesn't mean that you're making enough, or that you will make enough for your whole life.
b. your friends, relations, etc might be among those poor/exploited.
c. the kinds of relations that you get to have as a person in this society, and especially as a well-off worker, are poorer than they would be in a better world (one where people didn't have to worry about making ends meet, or only relating to other well-off people to avoid the conflict of having friends who are poorer than they).
d. the system doesn't actually work in a larger sense than just covering your basic food/housing/clothing/entertainment desires. i.e. you making money doesn't address things like environmental collapse, increasing child and elderly mortality/disease rates, etc.

i might be able to find a few more reasons, but that seems like a solid start.
by (53.1k points)
0 votes
I guess you like to be around people who are nice to you and who aren't suffering. The people around you will probably feel better if they themselves are part of a more happy community. From then on it's a question of balancing your social needs with your others.
by (590 points)